Can foam rollers be harmful
Although clinical trials have shown the use of foam rollers to be safe, experts warn they can be dangerous. The reason trials show they... Read Article
Massage guns are marketed a wonder tool you can use to do self massage and help recover after a workout, but are they worth getting or just another marketing gimmick? When we looked at the marketing, functionality and science behind massage guns we found:
In this article we will give you the actual facts (rather than the marketing BS) about massage guns, then look at your proven options that will cost less and do a great job.
Video overview
Summary
Percussion massage explained
What scientists think of percussion
A colleague's experiences with a Theragun
Are they even trying to make a serious therapeutic device?
Your better alternatives
References
Vibration massage is a proven therapy that professionals have been using for decades. Vibration massage machines work by having a vibrating pad that sits on the surface and sends in vibrations. Massage gun marketers came up with the gimmick “percussion” where instead of a pad the machines have a head that drives into your muscle like a jackhammer. They claim that this increases penetration and adds the benefits of conventional massage. However, as discussed below doing this reduces the amount of effective vibration while increasing the risk of doing harm and adding very little. You are far better off getting a genuine vibration massager.
If we look at this diagram the machine on the left is a vibration massager. As you can see it has a vibration pad designed to send large amounts of vibration deep into your muscles. The tool on the right is a t-bar, which massage therapists use these to save their thumbs and to apply deep (painful) pressure.
As you can see the massage gun in the middle is basically a t-bar with a jack-hammer mechanism. Compared with the vibration massager the head of the massage gun goes up and down a lot more, and is designed to drive into the muscle rather than send in vibrations.
The massage gun marketers will tell you about all the wonderful benefits of vibration. As discussed in our article Is percussion massage scientific this is very true. The problem is that massage guns don’t deliver anywhere near the amount of therapeutic vibrations that a proper vibration massager does.
Massage gun marketers will tell tell you that driving the head in increases penetration. However, it is the vibrations that have the therapeutic effects, and if you've ever used a vibration massager you’ll know that the vibrations can go right through you.
I don’t know of any scientific information that says driving the head in like a jack-hammer does anything worthwhile. Realistically the only thing it’s good for is hurting you. What’s going to happen if you use one of the hard plastic jackhammer heads and drive it into a nerve or blood vessel? Even using a percussion massager on muscles is not safe. There’s a journal report of someone nearly dying from internal bleeding after using one to help recover after a bike ride (2)
It’s not just me that’s saying that it’s a stupid idea driving the head in like a jack-hammer. When the scientists were asked to do clinical trials on massage guns they used special damper heads to stop the heads driving in and try and get a bit more vibration transfer (1,3). They did this to try and get better results and not hurt the patients. Of course this gets buried in the fine print and you are told that driving the head in like a jackhammer is a good idea.
The saving grace is that most of the massage guns that are flooding the market are not strong enough to do any serious damage, but I was speaking recently to a colleague who’d fallen for the marketing and brought a Theragun. They have a powerful jackhammer mechanism that drive the head in 16mm. She was telling me that she could only use it on slow speed, otherwise it would hurt her patients.
The main problem with this is as discussed in our article The best setting for your massager to get the proper therapeutic vibrations you need from 30-60 Hz (2,400-3,600 rpm) with the optimum being approximately 50 Hz. My colleague could not use her Theragun at anywhere near that speed because it would hurt people.
The word "gun" and the distinctive shape are a great marketing gimmick, but you need to ask yourself "would the manufacturer of a serious therapeutic device make one that you could not use effectively on a large portion of your body?"
So, hopefully you now understand that while massage guns claim to combine the benefits of conventional and vibration massage the reality is that they do neither well and are more likely to hurt you. You are best to stick to either genuine vibration or conventional massage. If you want the hand held device you can use yourself that will need to be a genuine vibration massager. Please see our article How to choose a massager
That said, as discussed in our article Why most massagers are a waste of money serious personal therapeutic vibration massagers are not that common. Most genuine vibration massagers are made for professionals to use on their patients, not personal use. Because of this, to get something decent for our patients we built our own.
This is our General Purpose Massager. The business end delivers copious amounts of therapeutic vibrations. Over the years we’ve sold over 100,000 of these without any advertising, mainly though professionals like chiropractors, osteopaths and physical therapists using them and recommending them to their patients.
More recently we’ve developed our quad head machine that has all the good things the General Purpose Massager has, but can do a much greater area at once and because the front part is larger and flatter you can easily use it like a cushion or chair massager.
We are continually adding more information on research and uses. Subscribe below to have us email them to you "hot off the press".
Several years ago Dr Graeme, a Chiropractor practicing in Victoria, Australia was looking for a serious hand held massager his patients could use at home to get the extra quality massage they needed. The ones he found in the shops and on-line for home use looked nice but were not serious, and... read more
Although clinical trials have shown the use of foam rollers to be safe, experts warn they can be dangerous. The reason trials show they... Read Article
Yes (myofascial) trigger points are a very large cause of shoulder pain. They have been found to be extremely common in sufferers of... Read Article
If you suffer from shoulder pain you will likely be given some analgesics to relieve the pain and some exercises to “correct” the... Read Article
Exercises are seen as a way to relieve shoulder pain and correct shoulder function. They are very useful as part of a rehabilitation... Read Article
Professional sports clubs have long used massage as a way to help their athletes, and more recently various self massage options have... Read Article
Clinical trials have shown that massage is effective in relieving fibromyalgia. However, the results show that some are better than... Read Article
Massage guns are marketed a wonder tool you can use to do self massage and help recover after a workout, but as we know marketers often... Read Article
Most movements require the co-ordinated contraction and relaxation of numerous muscles. The neurological control of this is known as a... Read Article
Using a hand held massager is simple. You place the vibrating head on the muscle, making good contact, and allow the vibrations to... Read Article
Most people do not get any where near the benefits they should from vibrating massagers, and even hurt themselves. This us because... Read Article
There are many different treatments for back pain. Should you see a chiropractor, get a massage, exercise or take drugs? There’s a lot... Read Article
Studies have shown that those suffering lower back pain have have inhibited sensory feedback and control. This lack of control is... Read Article
Tennis elbow is considered a difficult condition and too often does not respond to treatments, but this does not have to be. As I... Read Article
Many clinical trials have shown that massage reduces anxiety, along with a range of other symptoms such as pain, depression and high... Read Article
In this article we will discuss the health and wellness benefits of regular or wellness massages that have been scientifically... Read Article
There are a large number of things that can affects a sports persons reaction time such as fatigue, alcohol, lack of sleep and... Read Article
Sports massages are widely used and come with a host of claims such as that they increase performance and help recovery. However, when... Read Article
There is a lot of confusing and misleading information about what subluxation (complexes) are. Causes of this include: • the medical and... Read Article
Tennis elbow is a painful and disabling condition that is said to develop through overuse, but why does it then refuse to heal and defy... Read Article
Shoulder pain is very common, yet most of the common treatments such as exercises, medications and other therapies do little more than... Read Article
Do not refresh or leave this page until loading complete.