Are massage guns (percussion massagers) safe?
Massage guns (percussion massagers) are designed to drive their heads into your muscles. Most come with hard plastic heads while... Read Article
According to the results of many clinical trials massage can give great relief for fibromyalgia. However, while some massages worked well there is always the potential for the wrong massage to hurt or cause fibromyalgia to flare up. Further, the trials show that while individual massages can give temporary relief, to get long term improvement you need regular massages over time, so cost and convenience means we at least look at some self help options.
For an overview please check out our quick fibromyalgia massage demonstration video. Following that we have our more detailed information on the massages that work the best and how to apply them.
While general massage techniques can give some relief, techniques that target trigger points (tender lumps in your muscles) target the underlying problem and give better results. In this article we discuss how scientists found that trigger points are the biggest cause of fibromyalgia, and treating them gives great relief.
Fibromyalgia sufferers are highly sensitive so you need a technique that causes minimal pain, and it needs to start conservatively then increase as you become more tolerant.
You will need a very large number of applications of therapy. All the trials bar one used from 10 to 30 applications, but the relief was still incomplete. Also once the massage is stopped the symptoms gradually return. This means you will need to continue with regular therapy indefinitely.
The muscular conditions that need massaging are usually widespread on your body, therefore fibromyalgia massages tends to be prolonged “whole body” massages.
Because of 3 & 4 at least some therapy will need to be self therapy, or it will be extremely expensive and inconvenient.
The only massage that fits these well is vibration massage. This is where the head of a vibration massage machine is placed over the muscle to be massaged and the vibrations are allowed to penetrate and have their therapeutic effects. There are very large advantages in doing this. Because it is the vibrations that penetrate rather than any physical pressure:
In the next section we will show you how to choose a vibration massager and how to use it to get the best results.
Here we will outline what you need to look at when choosing a suitable vibration massager to treat fibromyalgia, then show the two DrGraeme massagers that are ideal. For more information please see our article How to choose a massager
You will need a strongly built massager that gives professional standard therapeutic vibration massage. Here is what to look for.
You will need a massager that can deliver therapeutic vibrations from 30-50 hz (cycles per second). Speeds are often quoted as RPM, so this is 1,800-3,000 rpm.
Please note that you will see machines with things like buttons, multiple speeds and led indicators. This is just pure gimmick and something that can easily fail. You are better off with a simple variable speed control like you would find on a quality power tool
You will likely need to massage places that are hard to reach so for self massage you will need a proper ergonomically designed handle. You will not be able to do this with a “Massage gun” shaped machine.
To transmit the therapeutic vibrations you need a comfortable flattish head. Manufacturers often include a variety of different heads, including shaped hard plastic ones that are designed to drive into the muscles rather than transmit vibrations. This is the last thing you need with fibromyalgia.
As we discuss in our article Vibration vs percussion massage, percussion massagers are designed to drive their heads in like jackhammers rather than to deliver therapeutic vibrations. Think of them as like meat tenderisers. They will give little therapeutic benefit while having a high probability of causing pain or a reaction.
As UK researchers found (1) manufacturers have a long history of concentrating on what their massagers look like on shop shelves rather than how they worked. Most are only marginally effective at best.
So our patients would have an effective massager to use at home, a few years ago we started building our own machines that had all of the desirable features of a fibromyalgia self massager and none of the things we need to avoid. These are now used, recommended and sold by a wide range of professionals across many countries, or available from us directly. For details please see our get a massager page.
We’ve had this machine for over a decade and it’s proved to be extremely effective, economical and reliable. The only shortfall is that you are limited to massaging the region under the single head. More information about the General Purpose Massager
This machine has the same ergonomic shape and effectiveness as the General Purpose Massager, but has four heads so it can massage a much larger area. More information about the Ultimate Quad Head Massager
Vibration massagers are extraordinarily easy to use. We have complete details including precautions in our vibration massage usage guide . However, basically all you need to do is to sit the head on the part to be massaged and let the vibrations penetrate. There is no need to press in or move the machine around like you would do with conventional massage. A lot of people do this, but it actually lessens the effectiveness.
We found 10 clinical trials that tested massage for fibromyalgia. The results are summarised below. They used the following types of massage.
It is not possible to directly compare because they use different numbers of treatments and measured things differently, but looking at them in total the following things are clear.
Myofascial release tended to give the best results overall, and produced better results than Swedish massage when when they were directly compared. Friction massage (painful) gave no benefits.
All but one of the trials used from 10 to 30 sessions of massage. On trial that monitored patients after the treatments had finished. They found that patients improved over the course of 15 massages, but those improvements gradually diminished over the six months.
The massage sessions were generally quite long with large areas of the body massaged.
As discussed in a separate article scientists have found that one of the main causes of fibromyalgia your nervous system being bombarded by pain from tender lumps in your muscles called (myofascial) trigger points over a long period of time. They found that stopping this pain greatly relieved the fibromyalgia. This would be why the massage technique that targeted trigger points (myofascial release) gave better results.
If you have fibromyalgia your nervous system will be sensitised. Therefore you will be less tolerant of painful therapies, and these could easily cause your condition to flare up. Also, fibromyalgia sufferers tend to have issues throughout many of their muscles. This is why the trials used long duration and “whole body” massage sessions.
We have a separate article that examines the various trigger point therapy options. We will briefly discuss the main ones here.
These are the massage techniques that gave the best results in the clinical trials. There are several variations, but they all involve finding the tender lump and applying pressure while that tenderness fades and the muscle relaxes. The down side is that these techniques are usually painful. Because fibromyalgia sufferers are extra sensitive these techniques need to be carefully applied and can easily cause a flare up.
These both need to be professionally applied so regular indefinite courses of therapy, each covering most of the body, would be very expensive. Lasers don’t hurt, but regularly being needled over a large portion of your body may not be pleasant.
This was not used in any of the trials, but based on our clinical experience and the science of trigger points it is as effective (if not more so) as any trigger point therapy. Further, it usually doesn’t hurt and with the right equipment can be easily self applied.
If you are a professional wishing to help your patients/clients with home trigger point therapy DrGraeme massagers were originally built by Dr Graeme for use in his clinic for this purpose and are now used by colleagues and other professionals for similar purposes. If you are a professional and wish to know more about this therapy, or possibly get a sample massager to trial please check out our practitioner page.
For your information we've summarised the results of the ten clinical trials of massage for fibromyalgia. As you can see they tended to use a large number of massage sessions and generally produced moderate relief. It is reasonable to believe that if care was continued the patients would continue to improve. The only trial where massage was not successful is where the painful therapy was used.
Study |
Massage used |
Duration, frequency, number |
Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
Mechanical massage device called Cellu M6 |
Fifteen weekly 35 minute sessions |
Improved pain, function and number of tender points points |
|
Friction massage vs stretching vs analgesics |
Uncertain |
Friction massage not beneficial. Friction massage is a painful massage not suited for fibromyalgia |
|
Compared Swedish massage with TENS machine |
Ten 30 minute sessions @ 2 per week |
Massage resulted in less pain, less fatigue, better sleep and lower anxiety |
|
Connective tissue massage |
15 sessions @ 1.5 per week |
Massage gives pain relief, relieved anxiety and improved quality of life. After treatments finished improvements gradually diminished over 6 months |
|
Swedish massage compared with standard physician care |
Ten sessions over 24 weeks |
Massage showed improvement, but only small numbers in trial |
|
Combination of styles |
30 minutes, twice a week for 5 weeks |
Less, pain, less anxiety and better sleep |
|
Myofascial release massage |
Weekly 90 minute session for 20 weeks |
Improved pain and quality of life |
|
Myofascial release |
Ten 60 minute sessions over 20 weeks |
Less tender spots, improved physical function |
|
Swedish massage vs myofascial release |
90 minute session weekly for 4 weeks |
Both produced pain reduction and improved movement. Myofascial release had better results |
|
Full body Shiatsu |
Sixteen 40 minute sessions @ twice a week |
Improved pain, tenderness and sleep |
We are continually adding more information on research and uses. Subscribe below to have us email them to you "hot off the press".
Several years ago Dr Graeme, a Chiropractor practicing in Victoria, Australia was looking for a serious hand held massager his patients could use at home to get the extra quality massage they needed. The ones he found in the shops and on-line for home use looked nice but were not serious, and... read more
Massage guns (percussion massagers) are designed to drive their heads into your muscles. Most come with hard plastic heads while... Read Article
In this article we will discuss the health and wellness benefits of regular or wellness massages that have been scientifically... Read Article
Trigger points are those tender lumps in muscles that therapists find. This article covers what they are, what they do, and how they are... Read Article
Tennis elbow is a painful and disabling condition that is said to develop through overuse, but why does it then refuse to heal and defy... Read Article
According to the results of many clinical trials massage can give great relief for fibromyalgia. However, while some massages worked... Read Article
The results of several clinical trials show that common tension headaches are typically caused by trigger points in the following... Read Article
When we look at the root cause of fibromyalgia we need to look at two levels: 1. the malfunction of the nervous system which causes the... Read Article
Trigger point release is a general term that describes procedures that relax tension and relieve pain in muscles that contain trigger... Read Article
Do not refresh or leave this page until loading complete.