Are massage guns a gimmick?
A gimmick is something that is not of real value used to attract attention, usually to get you to buy something. Massager guns certainly... Read Article
Clinical trials have shown that if you use vibration correctly it can over time improve the appearance of cellulite and actually reduce the size of hips, buttocks and thighs.
To show you what is possible the table below is directly from one of the trials. The third column of figures shows the actual reductions in measurements after just four weeks. In this guide we will discuss exactly how the scientists did this and how you can do it yourself.
While these have proven to be very safe and effective there are several claims and recommendations about using vibration that are totally inappropriate and even potentially dangerous. We will help make sure you are not affected by these.
An example of trial results
What is cellulite and how does it form
How does vibration help reduce cellulite
How the scientists got the results in the trials
How to do this at home
Vibration methods that don’t work or are dangerous
Frequently asked questions
Trial summaries and references
The following table taken from one of the clinical trials shows the actual reduction in size of hips, buttocks and thighs achieved after only four weeks of using vibration massage. We have also summarised the results of several other trials in the table below
In this section:
This diagram shows cellulite compared with normal skin. The yellow balls are fat cells. In the cellulite tissue the fat cells over-filled with fat and are much larger. This increases the size of the tissue, and are stretching the tissue that contains them gives the dimpled appearance
Why does this happen in some parts of your body while others remain normal? Scientists have found that the parts with cellulite have reduced circulation (about 35% less than normal) (1). Fat is deposited in these tissues, but when your body needs fat for energy the reduced circulation slows the re-absorption. Most of the fat instead is reabsorbed from tissues with normal circulation, so fat builds up in the cellulite tissues.
When used correctly vibration helps increase circulation, which allows the excess fat to be reabsorbed normally. Applications of vibration only increase circulation for a limited time but the reabsorption takes a long time, so the vibration needs to be repeated regularly over a long period of time.
For convenience the clinical trials used vibrating chairs or platforms to apply the vibration. This is something most people can easily do at home. We will discuss this, but we will also discuss a much more optimal way a professional might use vibration to increase circulation using affordable equipment that is safe, easy to use and available to the public.
To apply the vibration the scientists in the trials used readily available vibrating massage chairs and platforms. As we will discuss later these are not optimised for increasing circulation, but still increased circulation enough to help. If you have a vibration chair or platform we have links to the trial reports below so you may look them up and see what they did.
In the trials the scientists used these platforms to directly apply vibration rather than have people stand on them as they are usually used. In other words they sat them directly against cellulite tissues such as buttocks and thighs. As we discuss later standing on these plates as advocated hardly increases circulation at all. Basically all they do is make your muscles work a bit harder (for stability) when exercising.
Professionals such as Chiropractors and Physiotherapists regularly need to increase circulation when treating pain syndromes, injuries or during rehabilitation. When using vibration to do this they do not use chairs or vibration platforms. They use dedicated vibration massagers. These are available for the public and very easy to use, so in this section we will show you proper equipment and how to use it for the best results.
Standard disclaimer: This is general information only to be discussed with your health care professional, not specific advice.
In this section:
The therapeutic effects of vibration very much depend on the vibration frequency which is measured in Hz (cycles per second). For circulation the optimum frequency is about 50 Hz. To illustrate this one trial found that 50 Hz gave an excellent increase in circulation which stayed increased for about 30 minutes after the vibration stopped. By comparison 30 Hz gave a smaller increase which only lasted a few minutes (11).
The equipment you will need (a genuine vibration massager) will give vibrations at this frequency. As a contrast the chairs and vibration plates used in the clinical trials gave vibrations at a much lower frequency which is why they are not optimal for circulation.
As we will discuss later massage guns (percussion massagers) are designed to drive their heads into your muscles rather than sit on the surface and send in vibrations. Most come with hard plastic heads while the powerful ones drive their heads in 14-16mm. Driving something like that into your muscles 50 times a second would cause carnage, so massage guns cannot safely or comfortably be used at the optimum frequency for circulation.
This pic shows an example of a professional vibration massager . These have a head or pad that sits on the surface and are designed to send in large amounts of therapeutic vibrations at the right frequencies. If you use one you will feel the vibrations going "right through you", having a relaxing effect on your muscles, and of course increasing circulation. You will need a personal use version
Most vibrating massagers built for consumer use are built to look good on shop shelves rather than be serious therapeutic devices. These usually have low powered motors and inadequate mechanisms, so are not capable of delivering adequate vibration.
We have seen vibrating “massage wands” and a host of gimmicky cellulite massagers advertised. Their websites usually do not even give specifications, but from their appearance they look to be even less effective than the “consumer massagers”.
As discussed above, rather than having a pad that sits on the surface and sends in vibrations massage guns are designed to drive their heads in like jackhammers. Because of this they:
When we were looking for a suitable vibration massager for our patients to use all the effective machines seemed to be "professional" products for therapists to use. These were expensive and not designed for self use. Because of this we built our own that pack the effectiveness of a professional unit into an economical one for self use. They are now used, recommended and sold by over a thousand clinics across half the world (some examples). For information about these and where to get them please use these links.
We’ve had this machine for over a decade and it’s proved to be extremely effective, economical and reliable. The only shortfall is that you are limited to massaging the region under the single head. More information about the General Purpose Massager
This machine has the same ergonomic shape and effectiveness as the General Purpose Massager, but has four heads so it can massage a much larger area. More information about the Ultimate Quad Head Massager
The vibration massage usage guide has precautions and optimisation strategies, but using a vibration massager is extremely simple. You basically set the machine at the desired vibration frequency, sit the head or pad of the massager on where you want to massage, and let the vibrations penetrate. Please see this video for a practical demonstration.
To increase circulation the vibration needs to be applied directly to the cellulite tissues. Circulation needs to raised over a long period of time to allow the fat to be reabsorbed, but vibration only increases circulation for a limited time. To achieve their results scientists did things like sit the patients in the vibrating chairs daily for an hour at a time. However, if we use the proper equipment and vibration frequencies we can do a lot better than that.
As mentioned above the scientists applied lower frequency vibration that raises circulation a small amount and has only a very short residual effect. That meant to get a decent amount of increased circulation they needed to apply the vibration for long periods of time. However, 50 Hz applied by a proper vibration massager gives a larger increase with over 30 minutes residual effects. Therefore, using the proper equipment two applications of a few minutes each will give the same (if not more) increased circulation than 60 minutes with a massage chair or a vibration plate.
Vibration using a proper therapeutic vibration massager is very safe and comfortable. You could apply it a few times a day for a few minutes each time and get a far greater total increase in circulation that those sitting on a platform or chair for 60 minutes.
Vibrating your whole body by standing on a platform or using a vibrating exercise machine does not significantly increase circulation, and certainly does not have the same effect as applying vibration directly (8-10). These just cause your body to use more energy when exercising because your muscles need to work harder to maintain stability.
This do not target cellulite, just your total amount of fat. That is why any advertising you see will have something like “helps in combination with exercise and a healthy diet”. There are better ways to make your muscles work a bit harder and the same vibrations would be considered a serious health hazard in the workplace. Consider these a potentially harmful gimmick.
Massage guns are designed to drive their heads into your muscles rather than deliver vibrations. As discussed above this means that the amount of vibration they give is low and at the wrong frequency to increase circulation. This means any increase in circulation from using a massage gun is negligible.
We have read a lot of crazy claims such as that vibration causes fat cells to selectively die off, or that massage guns disperse or smash the fat cells. As we have seen in the pics of cellulite the fat cells are securely held in strong pouches so cannot be dispersed. Also, fat cells are fairly sturdy and cannot be easily smashed.
The biggest concern is the danger these false and irresponsible claims create. The fine blood vessels are far more delicate than the fat cells so any attempt to disperse of smash fat cells would result in internal bleeding. Mostly this just results in bruising, but people have nearly died from internal bleeding after using massage guns.
As the pic below shows there are a huge number of factories churning out ineffective gimmick cellulite massagers and “wands”. These are not serious therapeutic devices and would have no benefits for your circulation or cellulite.
If we look at the pic of cellulite above the problem is that the yellow fat cells contain too much fat. The only way to fix the problem is to reduce the amount of fat, and as we have seen it takes a long time for your body to do this. Most forms of cellulite treatment just flatten out those cells and squeeze some of the fluid out. Of course the cells eventually spring back into shape and more fluid seeps back in.
Using vibration as we have described will help your body normally re-distribute fat around your body. The total amount will remain the same.
Most of our massagers sell through colleagues using our machines and recommending the therapy to patients/clients, so we are very happy to send appropriately qualified professionals a complimentary sample machine to trial. For more info please see our Professional sample sample page .
Trial |
What they did |
Results |
Notes |
---|---|---|---|
30 or 60 minutes vibration daily for three weeks |
Reduced grading+ of cellulite |
||
Used 17.5-46 Hz vibrations for 30 or 60 minutes a day for three weeks |
Reduced grading+ of cellulite. Increased skin temperature |
Sub optimal vibrations |
|
15x 30 or 60 minutes locally applied 18-39 Hz |
Reduced grading+ of cellulite, increased skin temperature |
Sub optimal vibrations |
|
24 weeks of using hand held vibration wand. |
Visual improvement |
Used a device marketed as a cellulite wand, but no where near a serious therapeutic device. |
|
15 applications of 18-39 Hz vibration over three weeks. |
Decreased symptoms. Increased skin hydration. |
Sub optimal vibrations |
|
4 weeks of 17.5-46.5 Hz vibrations |
Decreased measurements for thighs, hips and waist |
Vibrations only 0.5mm so extremely poor penetration |
|
10 sessions of whole body vibration |
Increased skin temperature |
||
NOTES: |
For research or description cellulite is graded as follows. Where the grades were reduced in the trials that means that the cellulite improved.
We are continually adding more information on research and uses. Subscribe below to have us email them to you "hot off the press".
Several years ago Dr Graeme, a Chiropractor practicing in Victoria, Australia was looking for a serious hand held massager his patients could use at home to get the extra quality massage they needed. The ones he found in the shops and on-line for home use looked nice but were not serious, and... read more
A gimmick is something that is not of real value used to attract attention, usually to get you to buy something. Massager guns certainly... Read Article
Most professional athletes and sports clubs make heavy use of massage type treatments. The ability to do self massage using a hand held... Read Article
As a Chiropractor for over 27 years a lot of information I’ve seen about chiropractic adjustments has been misleading or just plain... Read Article
In this article we will discuss the health and wellness benefits of regular or wellness massages that have been scientifically... Read Article
Scientists have found that a high proportion of headaches result from pain coming from the muscles and joints of your head and neck. ... Read Article
Many clinical trials have shown that massage reduces anxiety, along with a range of other symptoms such as pain, depression and high... Read Article
Clinical trials have shown that massage is effective in relieving fibromyalgia. However, the results show that some are better than... Read Article
Do not refresh or leave this page until loading complete.